The Auto-Sleeper Motorhome Owners Forum (ASOF)
Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.

Lithium drop in replacement

+7
Peter Brown
treetops
Kevinktwo
Kemerton-bath
rgermain
Dbvwt
Alan WH
11 posters

Go down

Lithium drop in replacement  Empty Lithium drop in replacement

Post by Alan WH Wed Oct 20, 2021 10:08 am

I’m reading more and more of people having lithium batteries installed as a straight drop in replacement for the standard lead acid. Has anyone done it with a van conversion running through the sargeant  system ????
Alan WH
Alan WH
Member
Member

Male

Posts : 17
Joined : 2019-09-26
Location : skegness
Auto-Sleeper Model : symbol
Vehicle Year : 2024

Back to top Go down

Lithium drop in replacement  Empty Re: Lithium drop in replacement

Post by Dbvwt Wed Oct 20, 2021 4:08 pm

I can see the obvious performance, size etc… benefits of lithium batteries but at this moment they are silly money compared to a lead acid.
I camp off grid frequently and my power usage is typical of most others. If it wasn’t for the Sargent EC500 (let’s not go there for now!) my 110ah lead acid and standard 80w solar panel is more than adequate for my needs.
Can someone explain why, at this moment in time, there seems a trend for upgrading to lithium at great cost? For the majority, I can’t see the benefit.
Sorry Alan, didn’t mean to take your thread off in a different direction!
Dbvwt
Dbvwt
Member
Member

Male

Posts : 3196
Joined : 2018-10-04
Location : Aylesbury
Auto-Sleeper Model : Symbol
Vehicle Year : 2018

bikeralw, Suppersready, Kdc, Alan WH, IanH and FreelanderUK like this post

Back to top Go down

Lithium drop in replacement  Empty Re: Lithium drop in replacement

Post by rgermain Wed Oct 20, 2021 4:14 pm

Dbvwt wrote:I can see the obvious performance, size etc… benefits of lithium batteries but at this moment they are silly money compared to a lead acid.
I camp off grid frequently and my power usage is typical of most others. If it wasn’t for the Sargent EC500 (let’s not go there for now!) my 110ah lead acid and standard 80w solar panel is more than adequate for my needs.
Can someone explain why, at this moment in time, there seems a trend for upgrading to lithium at great cost? For the majority, I can’t see the benefit.
Sorry Alan, didn’t mean to take your thread off in a different direction!
Latest fad scratch head

I agree with you David, no problem this year, not been on EHU yet and never run out of juice smile!
---------
Richard
rgermain
rgermain
Donator
Donator

Male

Posts : 3643
Joined : 2013-11-21
Member Age : 77
Location : Havant
Auto-Sleeper Model : Warwick duo
Vehicle Year : 2015

Dbvwt, Alan WH, IanH and FreelanderUK like this post

Back to top Go down

Lithium drop in replacement  Empty Re: Lithium drop in replacement

Post by Kemerton-bath Wed Oct 20, 2021 10:22 pm

I really don’t see the point of a Lithium leisure battery as a drop-in replacement when the existing charging circuit isn’t rated to deliver the higher charging current demanded by Lithium to realise its full benefit.

Unless you take a complete system approach and upgrade charger, alternator, cabling and solar, then the advantage of Lithium seems very restricted. 

Tim

_________________
Previously symbol-bath

1996 - Autosleeper Symphony   2010 - Autosleeper Symbol    2018 - Autosleeper Kemerton   2023 - Autosleeper Kemerton XL (Fiat)
Kemerton-bath
Kemerton-bath
Donator
Donator

Male

Posts : 1170
Joined : 2013-01-06
Member Age : 65
Location : Bath
Auto-Sleeper Model : Kemerton XL (Fiat)
Vehicle Year : 2020

rgermain, Suppersready, Kdc, Alan WH and FreelanderUK like this post

Back to top Go down

Lithium drop in replacement  Empty Re: Lithium drop in replacement

Post by Kevinktwo Wed Oct 20, 2021 10:56 pm

I think Lithium is the future, the price is going to come down, however, I do think Autosleeper moving to Lithium before increasing the capacity to charge at the rate lithium can take is nuts, and for people who predominately use EHU, it is a waste of money.
Kevinktwo
Kevinktwo
Member
Member

Male

Posts : 77
Joined : 2021-05-11
Location : Gateshead
Auto-Sleeper Model : Warwick XL
Vehicle Year : 2021

rgermain and Alan WH like this post

Back to top Go down

Lithium drop in replacement  Empty Re: Lithium drop in replacement

Post by treetops Thu Oct 21, 2021 11:32 am

if its any help I have just finished a project on my kingham  to upgrade to lithium and the advantage of it  as I like using cl sites without hook up (which incidentally with electric prices soaring most sites will charge more!!) and the results are superb to the point it makes the basic system look ok for occasional use, I have used all renolgy equipment and probably cost about £900 in total, sergeant were very helpful with wiring diagrams and especially the exact wiring of a relay to isolate the vehicle battery when driving so that charging of the lithium battery is done via the dc to dc charger ,having spent a few days at leisure really enjoying the conversion the results perfect for my use ( incidentally I do have a 200 watt solar array and votronic controller to feed in which was already fitted before this conversion) so I can deffo recommend for anybody that feels confident to do the work and enjoys being off grid
treetops
treetops
Member
Member

Male

Posts : 35
Joined : 2019-02-09
Location : Isle of Skye
Auto-Sleeper Model : Kingham
Vehicle Year : 2018

Alan WH likes this post

Back to top Go down

Lithium drop in replacement  Empty Re: Lithium drop in replacement

Post by Guest Thu Oct 21, 2021 12:17 pm

Before making comparisons you have to make sure you use correct values of parameters

Due to higher depth of discharge for Lithium batteries a 100Ah SLA is equal to 68Ah LiFePo or conversely a 100Ah LiFePo4 is equivalent to around 150Ah SLA, who has the space for a 150Ah SLA and think about the weight.

LiFePo4 batteries are half the weight of the equivalent SLA

SLA have a charge cycle to 80% capacity count of 300 vs 2200 of LifePo4

You could expect to replace the SLA 5-7 times in the life of a LiFePo4

So this makes the value of LiFePo4 much better than SLA.


EXCEPT.....

Who is going to keep their motorhome for the life of 5 batteries?
Anonymous
Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

Lithium drop in replacement  Empty Re: Lithium drop in replacement

Post by Alan WH Thu Oct 21, 2021 1:29 pm

We rarely go on hookup and have been managing well with the standard battery/charger and alternator but at some time in the near future the battery will need replacement (4years old) and I’m thinking lithium.I’ve had a quote from an installer with all the extras that they say is needed and I just wondered if any one has just dropped a battery in and if extras are needed can be added later😎
Alan WH
Alan WH
Member
Member

Male

Posts : 17
Joined : 2019-09-26
Location : skegness
Auto-Sleeper Model : symbol
Vehicle Year : 2024

Back to top Go down

Lithium drop in replacement  Empty Re: Lithium drop in replacement

Post by Alan WH Thu Oct 21, 2021 1:34 pm

I don’t think I have the technical knowledge to do the electrical mods myself but nice to see someone happy with lithiums
treetops wrote:if its any help I have just finished a project on my kingham  to upgrade to lithium and the advantage of it  as I like using cl sites without hook up (which incidentally with electric prices soaring most sites will charge more!!) and the results are superb to the point it makes the basic system look ok for occasional use, I have used all renolgy equipment and probably cost about £900 in total, sergeant were very helpful with wiring diagrams and especially the exact wiring of a relay to isolate the vehicle battery when driving so that charging of the lithium battery is done via the dc to dc charger ,having spent a few days at leisure really enjoying the conversion the results perfect for my use ( incidentally I do have a 200 watt solar array and votronic controller to feed in which was already fitted before this conversion) so I can deffo recommend for anybody that feels confident to do the work and enjoys being off grid
Alan WH
Alan WH
Member
Member

Male

Posts : 17
Joined : 2019-09-26
Location : skegness
Auto-Sleeper Model : symbol
Vehicle Year : 2024

Back to top Go down

Lithium drop in replacement  Empty Re: Lithium drop in replacement

Post by Guest Thu Oct 21, 2021 2:29 pm

The “drop-in” replacements are called such because they incorporate battery management board that isolate the charging requirements from the charge source. Give them power at the terminals and the BMS takes care of it. 

These however are optimised for starter duties and I don’t know how applicable that would be for a leisure battery

These parameters would be software based so no reason why they could not be reprogrammed.
Anonymous
Guest
Guest


Back to top Go down

Lithium drop in replacement  Empty Re: Lithium drop in replacement

Post by Peter Brown Thu Oct 21, 2021 2:37 pm

HairyFool wrote:


EXCEPT.....

Who is going to keep their motorhome for the life of 5 batteries?

Its an idea; I would be motor homing till aged 95, the van would then be 35 and banned from every road in Europe. Like many aspects of life at my age, there is no time left to get a return on investment!
Peter Brown
Peter Brown
Donator
Donator

Male

Posts : 10597
Joined : 2012-11-10
Member Age : 72
Location : Staffs
Auto-Sleeper Model : Broadway EB
Vehicle Year : 2016

rgermain and Alan WH like this post

Back to top Go down

Lithium drop in replacement  Empty Re: Lithium drop in replacement

Post by IanH Thu Oct 21, 2021 3:41 pm

Simplicity, every time.
Anything Sargent avoid at all costs
Lithium will not get cheaper, demand for lithium is going through the roof for all sorts of things, esp elec cars.
Cost of average motorhome, let's say £30000 or so
Cost of SLA battery, circa £100 so 100/30000 = 0.00333
1/5 yrs, £20, irrelevant IMHO!!
110Ah SLA and circa 100w solar, all we've needed anywhere we've been!
IanH
IanH
Donator
Donator

Male

Posts : 8327
Joined : 2020-05-04
Location : NORTH WALSHAM
Auto-Sleeper Model : Executive
Vehicle Year : 2002

rgermain, MalMonty, Dbvwt, Alan WH and FreelanderUK like this post

Back to top Go down

Lithium drop in replacement  Empty Re: Lithium drop in replacement

Post by Dbvwt Thu Oct 21, 2021 3:48 pm

Alan WH wrote:We rarely go on hookup and have been managing well with the standard battery/charger and alternator but at some time in the near future the battery will need replacement (4years old) and I’m thinking lithium.I’ve had a quote from an installer with all the extras that they say is needed and I just wondered if any one has just dropped a battery in and if extras are needed can be added later😎

My leisure battery failed recently, it was just under 3 years old but I suspect the premature failure was because it wasn’t looked after at the dealers before I bought the van. A 110ah replacement cost just over £100 delivered and I expect to get at least 4 years out of it.
Lithium is definitely the future and if I was installing a complete new system (and had the budget!) then I would also go the way treetops has but on a 3 year old van a simple lead acid replacement that has served me 100% satisfactorily to date was the easy choice.
Dbvwt
Dbvwt
Member
Member

Male

Posts : 3196
Joined : 2018-10-04
Location : Aylesbury
Auto-Sleeper Model : Symbol
Vehicle Year : 2018

Alan WH likes this post

Back to top Go down

Lithium drop in replacement  Empty Re: Lithium drop in replacement

Post by Kevinktwo Thu Oct 21, 2021 8:12 pm

EXCEPT.....

“Who is going to keep their motorhome for the life of 5 batteries?”
The batteries can come across to your next Motorhome.
Kevinktwo
Kevinktwo
Member
Member

Male

Posts : 77
Joined : 2021-05-11
Location : Gateshead
Auto-Sleeper Model : Warwick XL
Vehicle Year : 2021

Alan WH likes this post

Back to top Go down

Lithium drop in replacement  Empty Re: Lithium drop in replacement

Post by Dbvwt Thu Oct 21, 2021 8:59 pm

Kevinktwo wrote:EXCEPT.....

“Who is going to keep their motorhome for the life of 5 batteries?”
The batteries can come across to your next Motorhome.

Wouldn’t that leave a big battery sized hole where you removed it from that would need filling? smile!
Dbvwt
Dbvwt
Member
Member

Male

Posts : 3196
Joined : 2018-10-04
Location : Aylesbury
Auto-Sleeper Model : Symbol
Vehicle Year : 2018

rgermain likes this post

Back to top Go down

Lithium drop in replacement  Empty Re: Lithium drop in replacement

Post by IanH Thu Oct 21, 2021 9:04 pm

Assuming the next MH can accept Lithium Batteries??????
IanH
IanH
Donator
Donator

Male

Posts : 8327
Joined : 2020-05-04
Location : NORTH WALSHAM
Auto-Sleeper Model : Executive
Vehicle Year : 2002

Back to top Go down

Lithium drop in replacement  Empty Re: Lithium drop in replacement

Post by Dbvwt Thu Oct 21, 2021 9:16 pm

IanH wrote:Assuming the next MH can accept Lithium Batteries??????

You are two steps ahead of me Ian!!
Dbvwt
Dbvwt
Member
Member

Male

Posts : 3196
Joined : 2018-10-04
Location : Aylesbury
Auto-Sleeper Model : Symbol
Vehicle Year : 2018

Back to top Go down

Lithium drop in replacement  Empty Re: Lithium drop in replacement

Post by andyfozz Tue Jan 24, 2023 4:50 pm

treetops wrote:if its any help I have just finished a project on my kingham  to upgrade to lithium and the advantage of it  as I like using cl sites without hook up (which incidentally with electric prices soaring most sites will charge more!!) and the results are superb to the point it makes the basic system look ok for occasional use, I have used all renolgy equipment and probably cost about £900 in total, sergeant were very helpful with wiring diagrams and especially the exact wiring of a relay to isolate the vehicle battery when driving so that charging of the lithium battery is done via the dc to dc charger ,having spent a few days at leisure really enjoying the conversion the results perfect for my use ( incidentally I do have a 200 watt solar array and votronic controller to feed in which was already fitted before this conversion) so I can deffo recommend for anybody that feels confident to do the work and enjoys being off grid
Hello, I have just purchased a 2018 Kingham and wish to upgrade , any pointers welcome, what system have you fitted amp hrs etc and did it include an inverter?
andyfozz
andyfozz
Member
Member

Male

Posts : 13
Joined : 2023-01-15
Location : Newcastle Under Lyme
Auto-Sleeper Model : kingham
Vehicle Year : 2018

Back to top Go down

Lithium drop in replacement  Empty Re: Lithium drop in replacement

Post by The Bargee Tue Jan 24, 2023 9:08 pm

Lithium batteries should never be regarded as drop in replacements.

Quite apart from the points already mentioned (inc. upgrading cabling, possibly alternator etc.) there is the fire and toxic fumes issue. LiFEPo4 are generally regarded as less prone to thermal runaway than some other lithium types but it can still happen. I can live with the risks of a lead acid battery in a habitation area but Lithium types really need to installed “outside” where there is less immediate danger from fire and the cocktail of toxic fumes that can be liberated.

Note also that some insurers would regard such a significant change to the vehicle spec as an unauthorised or notifiable modification.

It is telling that the maritime standards organisations that I deal with are still trying to formulate suitable standards and guidance for shipping and pleasure craft but the industry is moving faster than they can for obvious reasons (I.e. the imposition of ev’s) and there is simply not enough experience around yet. The people that say Lithium is safe are the people selling them!
The Bargee
The Bargee
Member
Member

Male

Posts : 676
Joined : 2022-12-27
Location : Rugby
Auto-Sleeper Model : Kingham
Vehicle Year : 2019

Back to top Go down

Lithium drop in replacement  Empty Re: Lithium drop in replacement

Post by clarkescribe Thu Oct 10, 2024 11:59 pm

Lead acid batteries are no safer than Lithium phosphate batteries when used properly. Charging a lead acid battery gives off hydrogen which is much more inflamable and likely to caue an explosion than a LiPo battery is to catch fire. There are more explosions caused by hydrogen from charging lead acid based batteris than fires from lithium phosphate based batteries. The lifetime and future of 12v batteris is Lithium based batteries as the price is already starting to drop and the lifetime costs are already lower. The problem is that LiPo batteries are not compatable with lead based battery chargers which gives us problem to those of us who wanting to upgrade. The problem is that you can't charge a lithium based battery with a lead acid based battery charge.
clarkescribe
clarkescribe
Member
Member

Male

Posts : 17
Joined : 2024-10-08
Location : North Essex
Auto-Sleeper Model : Symbol
Vehicle Year : 2020

Back to top Go down

Back to top

- Similar topics

 
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum