Solar Panel/Sargent EC328/12V Electrics Fault
+11
inspiredron
Cymro
dash
Driftwood6
Robbie
groundhog
brodco
DuxDeluxe
Peter Brown
-mojo-
Wearsider
15 posters
The Auto-Sleeper Motorhome Owners Forum (ASOF) :: Auto-Sleeper Motorhome Forums :: Auto-Sleeper "Coachbuilt Motorhomes" Forum
Page 4 of 4
Page 4 of 4 • 1, 2, 3, 4
Re: Solar Panel/Sargent EC328/12V Electrics Fault
Hope it works out ok. Mine is still working ok.
Guest- Guest
Re: Solar Panel/Sargent EC328/12V Electrics Fault
After having the same problem with 328 unit after solar installation it was good to read this thread.
Had the same response from sargent and am grateful for the upgraded panel with v 2.22 software from graig foot it seems to have addressed the problem and 12v is staying on, although it is early days yet reading other outcomes, am confident with upgrade outcome.
it is good to know there is still some good firms about
thank you
Dash
Had the same response from sargent and am grateful for the upgraded panel with v 2.22 software from graig foot it seems to have addressed the problem and 12v is staying on, although it is early days yet reading other outcomes, am confident with upgrade outcome.
it is good to know there is still some good firms about
thank you
Dash
dash- Donator
-
Posts : 23
Joined : 2011-11-09
Member Age : 72
Location : Devon
Auto-Sleeper Model : Devon
Vehicle Year : 2012
Not out of the woods yet.... EC328S
The new panel with V2.22 arrived by courier today but it has a different fault. It constantly shows a 61 amp discharge. Refitting the old panel returns charge/discharge to normal so obviously I have received a faulty replacement unit. Sargent are now closed for the weekend so I will hit the phone again on Monday. AAAGGGHHH!
Update. I have just found out that the unit can be re-calibrated by holding the selector for a couple of seconds whilst displaying the charge/discharge. Time for me to read up on this a little. I'LL BE BACK.........
Update. I have just found out that the unit can be re-calibrated by holding the selector for a couple of seconds whilst displaying the charge/discharge. Time for me to read up on this a little. I'LL BE BACK.........
Last edited by Driftwood6 on Fri Mar 20, 2015 3:27 pm; edited 2 times in total (Reason for editing : Found out more information)
Driftwood6- Member
-
Posts : 47
Joined : 2014-06-25
Member Age : 76
Location : Newport Shropshire
Auto-Sleeper Model : 2014 Nuveo EK
Vehicle Year : 2014
Recalibration when fitting a new EC328S panel
All OK. Lack of instructions anywhere in the manual or with the item but found out by applied logic that by holding the selector button down for two seconds whilst charge/discharge was displayed the unit calibrated itself and all seems fine now.
As a matter of interest I also have a problem with my outside temperature under-reading by six degrees and this problem has not sorted by changing the control panel (I was hoping it would). Sargent have sent me a new sensor but wire routing difficulties mean that I have not yet been able to install it to see if the problem is then solved. To be honest it is not worth disturbing the refrigerator connections, which would probablybe necessary) because of this minor problem so I will just live with it. Unless anyone knows better of course :)
As a matter of interest I also have a problem with my outside temperature under-reading by six degrees and this problem has not sorted by changing the control panel (I was hoping it would). Sargent have sent me a new sensor but wire routing difficulties mean that I have not yet been able to install it to see if the problem is then solved. To be honest it is not worth disturbing the refrigerator connections, which would probablybe necessary) because of this minor problem so I will just live with it. Unless anyone knows better of course :)
Driftwood6- Member
-
Posts : 47
Joined : 2014-06-25
Member Age : 76
Location : Newport Shropshire
Auto-Sleeper Model : 2014 Nuveo EK
Vehicle Year : 2014
Re: Solar Panel/Sargent EC328/12V Electrics Fault
Blast! Have just read these posts, Driftwood 6, and had I read them a few minutes earlier I would not have troubled Sargent with an email query.
My 2-week old Nuevo has the EC328S, with v2.22. All seems OK, apart from a strange reading for the Current, which like yours shows a discharge of -60.5 amps.
Thanks to your post, I'll try the remedy to recalibrate tomorrow morning (assuming no eclipse to mess up the solar!)
My 2-week old Nuevo has the EC328S, with v2.22. All seems OK, apart from a strange reading for the Current, which like yours shows a discharge of -60.5 amps.
Thanks to your post, I'll try the remedy to recalibrate tomorrow morning (assuming no eclipse to mess up the solar!)
Cymro- Donator
-
Posts : 3683
Joined : 2011-06-05
Location : Caerdydd - Cardiff
Auto-Sleeper Model : Nuevo ES
Vehicle Year : 2015
Re: Solar Panel/Sargent EC328/12V Electrics Fault
I apologise to Sargent because having read the manual again the recalibration info is clearly there in section 5.2 on page 12. If you don't have the manual it can be downloaded from here http://www.sargentltd.co.uk/EC328_User_Instructions.pdf
Driftwood6- Member
-
Posts : 47
Joined : 2014-06-25
Member Age : 76
Location : Newport Shropshire
Auto-Sleeper Model : 2014 Nuveo EK
Vehicle Year : 2014
Re: Solar Panel/Sargent EC328/12V Electrics Fault
Cymro wrote:Blast! Have just read these posts, Driftwood 6, and had I read them a few minutes earlier I would not have troubled Sargent with an email query.
My 2-week old Nuevo has the EC328S, with v2.22. All seems OK, apart from a strange reading for the Current, which like yours shows a discharge of -60.5 amps.
Thanks to your post, I'll try the remedy to recalibrate tomorrow morning (assuming no eclipse to mess up the solar!)
Success! Now gives a sensible current reading. Very many thanks for guidance.
Isn't this Forum a wonderful source?
Cymro- Donator
-
Posts : 3683
Joined : 2011-06-05
Location : Caerdydd - Cardiff
Auto-Sleeper Model : Nuevo ES
Vehicle Year : 2015
Re: Solar Panel/Sargent EC328/12V Electrics Fault
Cymro wrote:My 2-week old Nuevo has the EC328S, with v2.22.
Out of nothing more than curiosity, does anyone know what the "S" in EC328S refers to? I checked mine and it shows as being a EC328B (also with V2.22 because Sargent very kindly upgraded for me when I fitted a solar panel)? I concede that it ~might~ be because mine is supplied via B1lb0s, but that seems a bit unlikely...
-mojo-- Member
-
Posts : 4566
Joined : 2012-08-04
Member Age : 24
Location : Southeast
Auto-Sleeper Model : Trooper
Vehicle Year : 2006
Re: Solar Panel/Sargent EC328/12V Electrics Fault
I seem to recall that when I accidentally changed mine from 328 to 325 I had the option of S or B when I changed it back. I looked at the manual and the suffix was something to do with enabling certain optional features and EC328S seemed right for my van. Sargent manual not handy at present but easily available on line.
_________________
Best wishes - Ron
inspiredron- Member
-
Posts : 3436
Joined : 2012-06-02
Member Age : 83
Location : Ellesmere, Shropshire
Auto-Sleeper Model : Lancashire
Vehicle Year : 2012
Re: Solar Panel/Sargent EC328/12V Electrics Fault
I guess there must be more than one version of the manual out there then! I'm pretty familiar with the Issue 01 (June 2011) version, and that makes no reference at all to EC328B or EC328S (though the authors do seem a bit confused in places, as there is one reference to the EC500 and one to the EC325).
Perhaps I should just leave it alone though - it's often way too easy to fiddle with things that you don't need to fiddle with, as others have rightly pointed out to me here in the past!
Perhaps I should just leave it alone though - it's often way too easy to fiddle with things that you don't need to fiddle with, as others have rightly pointed out to me here in the past!
-mojo-- Member
-
Posts : 4566
Joined : 2012-08-04
Member Age : 24
Location : Southeast
Auto-Sleeper Model : Trooper
Vehicle Year : 2006
Re: Solar Panel/Sargent EC328/12V Electrics Fault
Sorry, I have checked the manual now and there is no reference to S or B.-mojo- wrote:I guess there must be more than one version of the manual out there then! I'm pretty familiar with the Issue 01 (June 2011) version, and that makes no reference at all to EC328B or EC328S (though the authors do seem a bit confused in places, as there is one reference to the EC500 and one to the EC325).
Perhaps I should just leave it alone though - it's often way too easy to fiddle with things that you don't need to fiddle with, as others have rightly pointed out to me here in the past!
Trawling my memory I can only think that I set it to the wrong version and a feature was then missing - I cannot remember what. It could have been external power for the whale water system, alarm, event timer - I really cannot remember now.
There is no problem in playing by setting to another version and then checking the menus.
_________________
Best wishes - Ron
inspiredron- Member
-
Posts : 3436
Joined : 2012-06-02
Member Age : 83
Location : Ellesmere, Shropshire
Auto-Sleeper Model : Lancashire
Vehicle Year : 2012
Re: Solar Panel/Sargent EC328/12V Electrics Fault
Perhaps a kind member with greater knowledge than I, could offer an opinion on 2009 Auto Sleepers Broadway super m/hme, which we have recently acquired and has a Sargent 325psu with a 130watt solar panel connected through the 325 solar connectio
The Auto Sleepers manual shows the solar panels fitted should be 20 to 100watt.
Can "trouble" be seen on the horizon with this setup?.
Thankyou.
Ed and Lynda
The Auto Sleepers manual shows the solar panels fitted should be 20 to 100watt.
Can "trouble" be seen on the horizon with this setup?.
Thankyou.
Ed and Lynda
Organplayer- Donator
-
Posts : 87
Joined : 2015-04-08
Member Age : 83
Location : West Berkshire
Auto-Sleeper Model : Northants
Vehicle Year : 2012
Re: Solar Panel/Sargent EC328/12V Electrics Fault
I think its Mojo who has detailed knowledge of the regulator Sargent use. I wouldn't imagine it a problem in northern Europe buy maybe southern Spain, Italy, Greece, etc. If visiting those areas it may be prudent to cover 25% of the panel - don't put any adhesive tape on the top surface of the panel.
Peter
Peter
_________________
Peter #1
Peter Brown- Donator
-
Posts : 10590
Joined : 2012-11-10
Member Age : 72
Location : Staffs
Auto-Sleeper Model : Broadway EB
Vehicle Year : 2016
Re: Solar Panel/Sargent EC328/12V Electrics Fault
The EC325 takes a max. 100W panel whereas the EC328 takes a max. Of 120W. I have a 100W panel fitted.Organplayer wrote:Perhaps a kind member with greater knowledge than I, could offer an opinion on 2009 Auto Sleepers Broadway super m/hme, which we have recently acquired and has a Sargent 325psu with a 130watt solar panel connected through the 325 solar connectio
The Auto Sleepers manual shows the solar panels fitted should be 20 to 100watt.
Can "trouble" be seen on the horizon with this setup?.
Thankyou.
Ed and Lynda
I would be inclined to ring Craig Foot at Sargent and ask if there is any danger to the PSU by having a panel exceeding the max.of 100W in your case.
moggyminor1966- Member
-
Posts : 462
Joined : 2011-08-14
Member Age : 78
Location : Somerset
Auto-Sleeper Model : None
Vehicle Year : None
Re: Solar Panel/Sargent EC328/12V Electrics Fault
Hi Moggyminor.Thanks for you prompt reply. I shall do as you suggest first thing Monday morning. I really had a job trying to impress upon the dealership/salesman that this installation was not right according to the AS manual, but was met with the statement that they have fitted 130watt solars many times before and no problems have ever come to light. I shall insist the solar connection is removed from the EC325 and a separate controller be installed or change the solar for a 100watt panel.
This being our 6th m/hme in 20 years, we have never had this question/problem before with any of them, and they were all fitted with solar panels. Again thanks for you input.
This being our 6th m/hme in 20 years, we have never had this question/problem before with any of them, and they were all fitted with solar panels. Again thanks for you input.
Organplayer- Donator
-
Posts : 87
Joined : 2015-04-08
Member Age : 83
Location : West Berkshire
Auto-Sleeper Model : Northants
Vehicle Year : 2012
Re: Solar Panel/Sargent EC328/12V Electrics Fault
My van of the last 3.5 yrs has an EC325 and it works very well if you understand it.
The EC325 is unique in the Sargent series of power supply/control systems. The charger is designed to 'fast charge' the Leisure battery using up to 18volts. As a voltage that high could destroy 12v habitation circuitry (including solar panel regulators), whenever the EC325 is on hook up and turned on it disconnects the 12v habitation circuitry from the leisure battery and charger. At the same time a separate regulated 12v power supply unit is connected to and powers the 12v habitation circuitry.
If you connect an independent solar panel regulator to the leisure battery of an EC325 system it is very likely to be damaged by the Sargent Charger so the regulator built into the EC325 must be used.
A solar panel connected to the EC325 charges both the leisure battery and vehicle battery when the van is not on hook up. If on hook up you can charge either the leisure battery or the vehicle battery (but not both together) by operating the appropriate switch on the control panel.
If constantly on hook up for a long period of time (over a week say) the leisure battery will start to lose electrolyte by gassing even though the charger is intelligent. Under these circumstances it is therefore a good idea to switch the charger off for a day every week to let the battery do some work. Sargent soon recognised this as an 'Achilles heel' of the EC325 so it was quickly replaced by the EC328 which has the leisure battery constantly connected and doesn't charge at such a high rate.
Peter
The EC325 is unique in the Sargent series of power supply/control systems. The charger is designed to 'fast charge' the Leisure battery using up to 18volts. As a voltage that high could destroy 12v habitation circuitry (including solar panel regulators), whenever the EC325 is on hook up and turned on it disconnects the 12v habitation circuitry from the leisure battery and charger. At the same time a separate regulated 12v power supply unit is connected to and powers the 12v habitation circuitry.
If you connect an independent solar panel regulator to the leisure battery of an EC325 system it is very likely to be damaged by the Sargent Charger so the regulator built into the EC325 must be used.
A solar panel connected to the EC325 charges both the leisure battery and vehicle battery when the van is not on hook up. If on hook up you can charge either the leisure battery or the vehicle battery (but not both together) by operating the appropriate switch on the control panel.
If constantly on hook up for a long period of time (over a week say) the leisure battery will start to lose electrolyte by gassing even though the charger is intelligent. Under these circumstances it is therefore a good idea to switch the charger off for a day every week to let the battery do some work. Sargent soon recognised this as an 'Achilles heel' of the EC325 so it was quickly replaced by the EC328 which has the leisure battery constantly connected and doesn't charge at such a high rate.
Peter
Peter Brown- Donator
-
Posts : 10590
Joined : 2012-11-10
Member Age : 72
Location : Staffs
Auto-Sleeper Model : Broadway EB
Vehicle Year : 2016
Re: Solar Panel/Sargent EC328/12V Electrics Fault
Thanks for that Peter.
A very clear description of something I only partially understood before. I knew there were reported problems with independent solar panel regulators when used with the EC325, but didn't know the reason.
The day is young - still time to learn something else new!
Dave
A very clear description of something I only partially understood before. I knew there were reported problems with independent solar panel regulators when used with the EC325, but didn't know the reason.
The day is young - still time to learn something else new!
Dave
Gromit- Donator
-
Posts : 7265
Joined : 2015-03-11
Member Age : 81
Location : Worcestershire
Auto-Sleeper Model : Nuevo EK LP
Vehicle Year : 2015
Re: Solar Panel/Sargent EC328/12V Electrics Fault
I should be doing something else but...
I've been doing a bit of research and the sort of solar controller/regulator we are looking at are rated at either 12v or 24v and by maximum current. The one installed in the Sargent unit is rated 12v at 10A and that is how they arrive at 120W max panel.
However solar panel specification all give a maximum output current and the maximum current I have found for a 150W panel is 8 amps, so that panel would be ok on the Sargent regulator.
If anyone can point me at anything that contradicts my logic, please do.
Peter
I've been doing a bit of research and the sort of solar controller/regulator we are looking at are rated at either 12v or 24v and by maximum current. The one installed in the Sargent unit is rated 12v at 10A and that is how they arrive at 120W max panel.
However solar panel specification all give a maximum output current and the maximum current I have found for a 150W panel is 8 amps, so that panel would be ok on the Sargent regulator.
If anyone can point me at anything that contradicts my logic, please do.
Peter
_________________
Peter #1
Peter Brown- Donator
-
Posts : 10590
Joined : 2012-11-10
Member Age : 72
Location : Staffs
Auto-Sleeper Model : Broadway EB
Vehicle Year : 2016
Re: Solar Panel/Sargent EC328/12V Electrics Fault
Thankyou Peter for all your trouble in pointing me away from a blinder of a mistake, in having a separate solar controller installed.
Do I understand you correctly in your last but one paragraph, where you I think refer to the 325 solar charger as 12v 10 amp, and mention that a panel of up to 150watts could be used with the 325 system. I have probably got "the wrong end of the stick" as the old saying goes, but thought I should be certain of your meaning.
Looks like I may have to get the dealers to change my 130watt solar panel for a 100watt.
Once again thankyou for your expertise. I really am a "numpty".
Ed
Do I understand you correctly in your last but one paragraph, where you I think refer to the 325 solar charger as 12v 10 amp, and mention that a panel of up to 150watts could be used with the 325 system. I have probably got "the wrong end of the stick" as the old saying goes, but thought I should be certain of your meaning.
Looks like I may have to get the dealers to change my 130watt solar panel for a 100watt.
Once again thankyou for your expertise. I really am a "numpty".
Ed
Organplayer- Donator
-
Posts : 87
Joined : 2015-04-08
Member Age : 83
Location : West Berkshire
Auto-Sleeper Model : Northants
Vehicle Year : 2012
Re: Solar Panel/Sargent EC328/12V Electrics Fault
http://1drv.ms/1FMXiCb
Above is a link to the data sheet for the solar controller that I believe is in the Sargent unit - I haven't taken mine apart to check as a very major job to remove it.
To clarify, what I am saying is that if the maximum output current of the panel you have fitted is 10A or less then you should be ok with this controller. Do you know the make and model of the installed panel?
Peter
Above is a link to the data sheet for the solar controller that I believe is in the Sargent unit - I haven't taken mine apart to check as a very major job to remove it.
To clarify, what I am saying is that if the maximum output current of the panel you have fitted is 10A or less then you should be ok with this controller. Do you know the make and model of the installed panel?
Peter
_________________
Peter #1
Peter Brown- Donator
-
Posts : 10590
Joined : 2012-11-10
Member Age : 72
Location : Staffs
Auto-Sleeper Model : Broadway EB
Vehicle Year : 2016
Re: Solar Panel/EC325 Sargent Controller
My Solar panel was fitted when I bought the van second hand, I don't know why but the dealer fitted a separate controller
rather than connecting into the Sargent unit. I can only assume they did not know that this could be done. On reading various
reports about the possible problems in doing it this way I rang Sargent's technical department who assured me that it would
not be a problem, that was 18 months ago.
David
rather than connecting into the Sargent unit. I can only assume they did not know that this could be done. On reading various
reports about the possible problems in doing it this way I rang Sargent's technical department who assured me that it would
not be a problem, that was 18 months ago.
David
cyclo- Member
-
Posts : 124
Joined : 2014-02-27
Member Age : 77
Location : West Yorkshire
Auto-Sleeper Model : Broadway EKTBLP
Vehicle Year : 2018
Re: Solar Panel/Sargent EC328/12V Electrics Fault
I don't think that is what Peter is saying. In his experience a 150W panel is only giving 8A maximum which is les than 10A. Your 130W should give less than 8A unless it is a very efficient panel. so if that is so there is no need to change it to a 100W. In any event 130W is so little over 120W that it is likely to be within the manufacturer's tolerance. If they say that 120W is OK it is very likely that 150W would be. They have to be conservative in saying what is OK.Organplayer wrote:Looks like I may have to get the dealers to change my 130watt solar panel for a 100watt.
Ed
_________________
Best wishes - Ron
inspiredron- Member
-
Posts : 3436
Joined : 2012-06-02
Member Age : 83
Location : Ellesmere, Shropshire
Auto-Sleeper Model : Lancashire
Vehicle Year : 2012
Re: Solar Panel/Sargent EC328/12V Electrics Fault
I'd agree with the above conclusions from what I've learned about the EPIPDB-COM controller in the EC328 (and I think the same one is used in the EC325?).
I think it is unlikely that a 130W panel will be able to exceed the 10A limit of the controller in UK or even Southern European conditions - and I also suspect that there has been an element of "marketing interpretation" of the power output on these Chinese panels (in that they have found that if they state the power as 130W they get to sell a lot more of them than if they state the power as 120W) anyway. I've looked at a few and there seems to be some creative thinking going on there...
One thing that may be worth looking into, though, are the settings on the controller. When I looked at mine, it seemed to be set to factory defaults, which may not be entirely appropriate. This is not Sargent's fault as they don't know the type of install that the EC328 will be used in, but I was a bit disappointed that the converter of my van (not Auto-sleeper I should add) had not bothered to change it to something more appropriate.
On mine one setting was not very sensible (it was set to distribute solar power 50:50 between vehicle and leisure battery, even though a typical camper will use hardly any vehicle battery power when parked up on site) but the one that would be worth checking is that the battery type has been set correctly. Mine was not, and if they left that with the wrong setting you may risk too low or too high a terminal voltage on your batteries. However, it should not be ~too~ critical, as the battery type setting doesn't affect the float charge voltage, and that's probably the most important one in terms of keeping your batteries in good condition long-term.
I think it is unlikely that a 130W panel will be able to exceed the 10A limit of the controller in UK or even Southern European conditions - and I also suspect that there has been an element of "marketing interpretation" of the power output on these Chinese panels (in that they have found that if they state the power as 130W they get to sell a lot more of them than if they state the power as 120W) anyway. I've looked at a few and there seems to be some creative thinking going on there...
One thing that may be worth looking into, though, are the settings on the controller. When I looked at mine, it seemed to be set to factory defaults, which may not be entirely appropriate. This is not Sargent's fault as they don't know the type of install that the EC328 will be used in, but I was a bit disappointed that the converter of my van (not Auto-sleeper I should add) had not bothered to change it to something more appropriate.
On mine one setting was not very sensible (it was set to distribute solar power 50:50 between vehicle and leisure battery, even though a typical camper will use hardly any vehicle battery power when parked up on site) but the one that would be worth checking is that the battery type has been set correctly. Mine was not, and if they left that with the wrong setting you may risk too low or too high a terminal voltage on your batteries. However, it should not be ~too~ critical, as the battery type setting doesn't affect the float charge voltage, and that's probably the most important one in terms of keeping your batteries in good condition long-term.
-mojo-- Member
-
Posts : 4566
Joined : 2012-08-04
Member Age : 24
Location : Southeast
Auto-Sleeper Model : Trooper
Vehicle Year : 2006
Page 4 of 4 • 1, 2, 3, 4
Similar topics
» Solar Panel and Sargent EC328 revisted
» Sargent EC328s Control Panel
» Fault on Sargent EC200 Control Panel
» Broadway Sargent control panel fault
» Solar Panel/SargentEC328/12v Electrical Fault
» Sargent EC328s Control Panel
» Fault on Sargent EC200 Control Panel
» Broadway Sargent control panel fault
» Solar Panel/SargentEC328/12v Electrical Fault
The Auto-Sleeper Motorhome Owners Forum (ASOF) :: Auto-Sleeper Motorhome Forums :: Auto-Sleeper "Coachbuilt Motorhomes" Forum
Page 4 of 4
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum